Critical Digital Literacy Education Guide

11 activity 13: FACT-CHECKING IN ACTION — INFOGRAPHICS Infographics visualize data and facts in a compelling way, but as with a news article, the “facts” of the graphic need to be checked. Infographic Reliability Criteria: • The original source of the data should be cited, and the source should be reliable. • The original data should be accessible for fact-checking from the source website. • Reliable sources often provide details of the research methodology and interpretation of the data, including sample size and outcomes. Fact-checking Infographics Infographics create a visual narrative. They use data and statistics to communicate a message. When this is done well, infographics make data accessible and easy to understand. However, this data can also be manipulated, fabricated, or misrepresented. In these cases, an infographic can spread misinformation and disinformation widely. Sharpen your fact-checking skills by testing the accuracy of infographics shared on Twitter. 1. Working in pairs, go to @StatCan_eng on Twitter. Identify an infographic that you find interesting, or work with your teacher to choose a relevant infographic. 2. Examine the details to determine the source of the data used in the infographic. 3. Use the Fact-Checking in Action Worksheet to conduct your investigation: go “upstream” to find the original data. 4. After completing the fact-checking steps, make an assessment of the accuracy of the infographic based on your findings. Assign a grade to the infographic based on how factual it is: A+ for perfectly communicating the facts from a reliable source; F for wildly manipulating the data or creating false data. Extension 1: Work in pairs to use the “Data” section of the Statistics Canada website to create your own infographic. Work with your teacher to select an appropriate subject from the data library. Choose five to ten data points to visualize in your infographic, using online software or drawing by hand. Ensure you cite the source of your data as well as any relevant research methodology from the original source. Extension 2: Investigate the reliability of an infographic you find on a social media site. Can you determine the original source of the data? Is the source reliable? Do the data support the story the infographic is telling? EXAMPLE: “Chocolate Makes you Smarter” • If we look closely at this infographic, we see that the research was paid for by a chocolate company. • This is a red flag. It suggests that the research is biased (of course a chocolate company wants to “prove” that chocolate makes you smarter!). • No additional details about the research are cited, which is another red flag for potentially unreliable information. After examining a source, whether or not you suspect it is “fake news,” you still need to check the facts. Sources sometimes provide half-truths, where most of the content is based in fact but with bits of misinformation sprinkled in. Sometimes a “spin” is put on the facts, or the original content is interpreted differently by a secondary source. Quotes can be taken out of context or fragmented, which could change their meaning. Sometimes, misinformation is deliberately pushed through social media ads. Sometimes, though, a publication simply makes an error. In the age of 24-hour news cycles, reporting on breaking news — such as a natural disaster or a shooting — means the details can take time to emerge. As news organizations fill the space in between new developments, misinformation can find its way into the coverage. Occasionally even trustworthy sources can get the facts wrong, without intentionally sharing false information. section 4: check the facts With any piece of digital media, it is important to check the facts before you share. There are three steps to take when checking the facts: 1. Compare multiple sources and perspectives • Treat the piece of media as a jumping-off point. If it is legitimate and factually accurate, you should be able to find other sources that support its contents. • However, just because you can find information to support a claim doesn’t make it legitimate. We are all susceptible to confirmation bias. 2. Go “upstream” to find original sources • Using the information you have, track the facts “upstream” to find the original source of the claims. • Open a new tab or window on your device and search for the content in question. It can be easy to fall down a rabbit hole online, so tracking your fact-checking is important. Keep tabs open in your browser to refer back to later. • Determine whether the facts are fully accurate, or whether details have been lost or changed. • For photographs and illustrations, use Google’s reverse image search to find out where else the image appears online. This will help you determine whether the image originated from a reliable source. 3. Use a fact-checking website • Professional fact-checkers review many news stories and publish their findings online. • Use a reliable fact-checking website to confirm your own assessment. Man operates a video camera (nampix/Shutterstock.com/556157896). Fictional infographic about the alleged benefits of chocolate (Historica Canada, 2019).