Think Like a Historian: Introduction to the Halifax Explosion

4. ETHEL BOND - CONT’D Compare two or more individuals’ experiences of the Halifax Explosion. Is there enough evidence in other sources to corroborate Ethel Bond’s account? 1. In pairs, compare Ethel Bond’s letter to her sister’s letter in the Primary Sources Supplement in the Ethel Bond Worksheets Package on the Education Portal . Using the Finding Proof Chart , also in the Ethel Bond Worksheets Package , compare and contrast Bond’s account with this other account. Record your findings in the chart. Consider the following questions when making your assessments: • How is Ethel’s perspective on the Explosion different from another survivor’s? • How is it the same? 2. Discuss the similarities and differences you noted with another pair. Record your findings in your notebook. • Are the accounts more similar or different? • What are the most important similarities or differences? Are there inconsistencies? • What does this tell you about the reliability of individual sources? • What does comparing perspectives reveal to you about the Explosion? 3. Are there still any gaps in your understanding of the experience of different people living and working in Halifax at the time? What accounts or whose voices are you still seeking? Create your own sketches of visual descriptions in the letter as you watch and listen to the video at least twice. Alternatively, read the letter transcript aloud while students sketch their vignettes. Note to teachers: As you study the details of the letter, develop conclusions based on what you observe and what you can infer. What can we learn about Ethel Bond’s experiences from her letter? Record your observations, hypotheses and conclusions in the Reaching Conclusions Chart in the Ethel Bond Worksheets Package on the Education Portal . As a class, discuss what we can learn about the Explosion from Ethel Bond’s letter. • What does the evidence suggest about Ethel Bond’s thoughts and feelings about the Explosion? • What has this letter taught you about one person’s perspective on what it was like to live through the Explosion? Reread and analyze Ethel Bond’s letter. A close reading is important to gain a deeper understanding of Ethel Bond’s experiences. 1. In pairs, identify and define any unfamiliar words or phrases. 2. Underline or circle words or phrases in the letter that offer clues about Ethel Bond’s feelings and thoughts, and what was important to or valued by Bond. 3. Explore the letter to understand her experiences using the five senses. Briefly summarize what Bond describes seeing and hearing, and make inferences about what she might have smelled, tasted, or touched. Teacher Tip: Prompt students to look out for sentences that don’t make sense even though they may know the meaning of the words. Consider printing copies of the letter for students. Word Key Magazine: place to store ammunitions Rent: pierced or disturbed with sound Harrow up : to deeply disturb or distress C) EXPLORING D) REACHING CONCLUSIONS Letter from Ethel Jane Bond to Murray Kellough, 16 December 1917 (courtesy Nova Scotia Archives/ Murray Kellough fonds/2010-015). Map and Guide of Halifax City, c . 1880s (courtesy Halifax Public Libraries Digital Collections/Vintage Halifax City Guides). Modification Ethel Bond (young adult), c . 1911 (private collection of Koralee King). Letter from Ethel Jane Bond to Murray Kellough, 16 December 1917 (courtesy Nova Scotia Archives/ Murray Kellough fonds/2010-015). E) FINDING PROOF