Historica Multiculturalism Education Guide

Activity: Indigenous Peoples and Genocide in Canada In 2019, the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (an independent national inquiry commissioned by the Government of Canada) announced its findings. The inquiry used the term genocide to characterize the pattern of violence against Indigenous women and girls in Canada (as well as Indigenous peoples, in general) and the federal government’s response to these systemic human rights violations. According to the inquiry, the primary reason for the higher rates of violence against Indigenous peoples in Canada is the “persistent and deliberate human and Indigenous rights violations and abuses.” The final report argued that various colonial laws, policies, and programs, such as the Indian Act and the child welfare system, are intent on “destroy[ing] Indigenous Peoples.” The Chief Commissioner of the inquiry, Marion Buller, said of the report, “[it] is about deliberate race, identity and gender-based genocide.” 1 On 4 June 2019, while speaking to a crowd in Vancouver, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau recognized the inquiry’s conclusions, saying: “we accept the findings of the commissioners that it was genocide.” 2 While many in Canada recognize the atrocities against Indigenous peoples, use of the term genocide has generated some backlash among those who do not believe the term is appropriate or warranted. However, others argue that use of the term is important, and that downplaying the inquiry’s findings overlooks and undervalues the lived experiences of Indigenous peoples in Canada. The inquiry’s use of “genocide” influenced important changes. Notably, the Canadian Museum for Human Rights decided to change its description of the atrocities committed against Indigenous peoples in Canada from “cultural genocide” to “genocide.” While Canada is a multicultural country, the deliberate repression and suppression of Indigenous peoples and their cultures has long gone against this so-called inclusivity. In recent years, steps have been taken to make amends and improve the relationship between Indigenous peoples and Canada. 1 The Canadian Encyclopedia. “Genocide and Indigenous Peoples in Canada.” The Canadian Encyclopedia . Historica Canada. Article published November 02, 2020; Last Edited November 02, 2020. 2 https://vancouver.citynews.ca/2019/06/04/trudeau-accepts-the-finding-of-genocide-but-says-focus-needs-to-be-on-response/ teacher tip: If students are uncomfortable expressing themselves on this sensitive topic, instead of a class discussion, ask students to write a report on their thoughts and findings. Intersectionality and Multiculturalism in Quebec In Quebec, federal multiculturalism policies led to concerns about French culture being undermined and given the same weight as all other non-Anglo-Canadian groups. As a result, alternative measures and interpretations of multiculturalism were taken in Quebec. In 1977, Bill 101 was passed, making French the official language of Quebec in an attempt to replace the federal policy of “multiculturalism within a bilingual framework” with one of unilingual cultural pluralism. This was followed by a formal rejection of federal multiculturalism in 1981. Instead, Quebec has adopted a policy of “cultural convergence” that promotes cultural integration or, in other words, “many ways of being a Quebecer,” with French as the dominant language and culture. Most recently, in 2019, Bill 21 became law in Quebec. Bill 21 is “an act respecting the laicity of the State” that emphasizes the separation of the state and religion. Controversially, it regulates how people are allowed to express their religious beliefs in the workplace. It has been criticized as disproportionately affecting already marginalized groups and for running counter to the policies of multiculturalism and freedom of expression and religion. 18